Think of all the people who were so certain that Judy was Josie's sister. "Josie" even wrote a letter about her sister Judy. It seemed very straightforward.
This isn't being constructed according to a logical vision, although occasionally logic works in it.
Given we see Josie among the few people from Twin Peaks in the "Laura's body gone" sequence and then Judy/Sarah Palmer wrecking the picture I would think that Josie is Judy's sister is far from dead.
Yeah we don't even know if Josie is a human--the whole weird autopsy thing. She might be some lodge thingy.
Sorry, correction - I meant the Roadhouse scenes rather than Double RR scenes.
Possibly explaining their disconnection from the familiar side of Twin Peaks that the viewer normally knows.
8 - part 8?