I think Judy got into the Palmer house by they picture Mrs Tremond told Laura to put on her wall. Thus establishing a portal between lodge world and Palmer house.
I like all the above theories except the word mother keeps irking me. Experiment okay, Judy okay, mother naw, no evidence
I think Judy got into the Palmer house by they picture Mrs Tremond told Laura to put on her wall. Thus establishing a portal between lodge world and Palmer house.
Good idea. I hadn't thought of that picture being used as a portal outside of FWWM. Why not!?
To me the evidence points to Judy being the thing/experiment that created Bob in episode 8 and thus the creator of all the evil in Twin Peaks. The thing that is in Sarah Palmer and that came through in New York to kill the couple having sex is the same thing or looks similar and connected to Judy in some way which people have called Mother. Sex is used as a way of attracting this Mother figure as in the couple having sex and Diane/Linda and Cooper/Richard having sex to attract Judy's presence into the alternative universe that they have driven into. The Chalfonts and Tremonds have occupied the Palmer's house in this universe that Judy seems in control of or trapped in by the Fireman. Cole says they are after an entity called Judy. Bad Cooper as also met Judy. To me all the evidence points to Judy being the experiment figure who created Bob in episode 8 and in possession of Sarah Palmer in the form of that figure that is called Mother. Whether the girl in episode 8 is Sarah and is possessed by Judy through the frog moth climbing inside her I am unsure of though I do think about the parallels between that scene and the Wizard of Oz that Judy Garland falls asleep in Kansas in black and white and then dreams about going to Oz. Maybe there is some type of connection there or not. Also Phillip Jeffries meeting a Judy in Buenos Aries may not tie up with Sarah Palmer being possessed by Judy and seems to do with a real person rather than an entity called Judy.
I read carefully, but where are EVIDENCES ? Most of your things is faith. The one who you call Judy sent to Earth hundrets of eggs and one Bob Orb. And this being is shown as flying beyond our reality. There is no point that something so big and powerfull are interested in one couple sex. There is thousend of people doing sex in every minutes. And ofcourse our big Judy flying somewhere beyond our reality is interesed in Cooper and Diane sex. There is no EVIDENCE in this movie that this creature is interested their sex. It is your theory with no evidences at all.
I think the evidence comes from the secret history book. Have you read it?
I think the evidence comes from the secret history book. Have you read it?
Quote or write me a page, I check myself. Where is there a proof that this big being flying beyond our reality in a movie, who spits hundreds of eggs is the same who is interested in Cooper and Diane sex. I am waiting for EVIDENCES !
I never did buy the idea. Anything regarding Sarah Palmer's possessor/co-traveller is conjecture, nothing more. All we know is there's something in there, but we don't even know what its intentions are, other than to kill potential rapists.
We also know there is something in her kitchen or the surrounding area.
Be careful agreeing with me, that can be habit forming and lead to madness and other more nefarious results.
I can vouch for that. 😉
When she is stabbing Laura's photograph does it sound like the "noises in her kitchen" are coming from somewhere else? To me it does but it's hard to say because I'm watching on a laptop.
When she is stabbing Laura's photograph does it sound like the "noises in her kitchen" are coming from somewhere else? To me it does but it's hard to say because I'm watching on a laptop.
Thus why I added in surrounding areas. Didn't want anyone feeling the need to fervently correct me.
When she opens the door to Hawk, we assume the sounds are coming from the kitchen. But that may not be the case. They may be coming from the dining room or the den or the living room or the downstairs bathroom. 🙂
What I meant to say was are the noises coming out of her or coming from elsewhere in the house? I wasn't trying to nitpick about the kitchen specifically, I was just trying to identify if it's Sarah making the noises or if they are coming from elsewhere in the house. This is clearly a pivotal scene but I'm still not convinced of it's true meaning.
What I meant to say was are the noises coming out of her or coming from elsewhere in the house? I wasn't trying to nitpick about the kitchen specifically, I was just trying to identify if it's Sarah making the noises or if they are coming from elsewhere in the house. This is clearly a pivotal scene but I'm still not convinced of it's true meaning.
I didn't think you were nitpicking. 🙂 I was just preparing to be nitpicked.
When Hawk checks on her, it is definitely NOT the Sarah we understand and know making noises. As for the night she stabs the pic, I could never tell. Would take someone with better hearing than I.
Fire walk with